Renovated 1909 two-story home at 457 N C Street in Salt Lake City's Avenues neighborhood — sold with a reduced listing commission from DiscountAgent.com


DiscountAgent.com Blog • Seller Success Story
SOLD — Seller Represented

A turn-of-the-century 2-story home in Salt Lake City’s historic Avenues neighborhood received multiple offers in its first day on the market — and our seller saved approximately $21,000 at closing with a reduced listing commission from DiscountAgent.com.

By Aaron Peters, Broker/Owner • April 27, 2026 • Salt Lake City, UT 84103
Property Sold
457 N C Street
The Avenues • Salt Lake City, UT 84103 • Salt Lake County
3
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
2,552
Sq Ft
1909
Year Built
Approximate Seller Savings
Approximately $21,000
That’s money this seller kept in their pocket at closing — savings achieved through a reduced listing commission with DiscountAgent.com instead of a traditional full-commission listing.
Note: Utah is a non-disclosure state, so actual sold prices are not publicly reported. The savings figure above is approximate and reflects the difference between our reduced listing commission and what a traditional full-commission listing would have cost on this transaction.

About the Home: A Fully Renovated 1909 Two-Story in The Avenues

This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom 2-story home on C Street offered the rare combination of historic character and modern systems. Built in 1909 and updated extensively, the property went through a complete renovation that included new HVAC, plumbing, and electrical — the kind of behind-the-walls work that buyers in The Avenues actively seek out but rarely find. The 2,552-square-foot home sits on a 0.11-acre lot with full landscaping, mature trees, and a covered front porch that captures the classic Avenues streetscape.

The interior featured an open main floor flowing between kitchen, living, and dining spaces — an updated layout that still respected the home’s turn-of-the-century roots. The kitchen was the standout: an island with a gas range, a butler’s pantry, and tons of natural light. Three bedrooms upstairs shared one full bath (primary) and one three-quarter bath, with the primary bedroom on the second floor. The lower level was finished and offered additional flex space, while a detached garage and entertaining-friendly backyard rounded out the package.

Students in this part of The Avenues are assigned to Ensign Elementary, Bryant Middle School, and West High School — all part of the Salt Lake City School District. You can browse other active listings on our The Avenues homes for sale page.

How the Listing Commission Savings Worked

In a traditional Utah real estate transaction, the seller typically pays around 3% to the listing brokerage — separate from whatever is offered to the buyer’s side. On a higher-priced Avenues home, that listing-side fee adds up to a serious chunk of the seller’s equity. At DiscountAgent.com, our standard seller program charges a 1.5% listing commission, cutting the listing fee in half while still providing full MLS marketing, professional photography, pricing strategy, negotiation, and closing support.

On this particular transaction, the sellers were past clients of ours and qualified for an even more aggressive savings structure — our flat-fee listing program, which is offered exclusively to repeat clients as a thank-you for their continued trust. That program replaces the percentage-based listing commission with a single flat fee, which on this sale came out to roughly $21,000 in total seller savings at closing.

The marketing and service level didn’t change. The home was professionally photographed, syndicated across the MLS and major real estate portals, strategically priced based on live comparable Avenues data, and actively promoted. The listing went live and generated multiple offers within the first day — a strong indicator that the pricing strategy and presentation hit the mark. The seller received the same full-service experience any DiscountAgent.com listing gets; the only thing that changed was how much of the sale proceeds they kept.

The Avenues Seller Commission Savings by Price Point

Here’s what the math looks like across typical Avenues-area price points for our standard 1.5% listing program (available to all sellers), compared against a traditional 3% listing commission. Savings shown represent the listing-side commission only and do not account for the buyer-side commission, which is negotiated separately.

Sale PriceTraditional 3%Our 1.5%You Save
$620,000 $18,600 $9,300 $9,300
$720,000 $21,600 $10,800 $10,800
$820,000 $24,600 $12,300 $12,300
$920,000 $27,600 $13,800 $13,800
$1,100,000 $33,000 $16,500 $16,500
$1,300,000 $39,000 $19,500 $19,500

Table shown for general illustration only. Actual savings depend on final sale price, terms, and transaction specifics.

All commission rates are negotiable and not set by law. Figures are not guaranteed. DiscountAgent.com’s flat-fee listing program is available exclusively to past clients and is separate from the 1.5% program shown above.

Quick Facts About This Sale

Subdivision
The Avenues
County
Salt Lake County
Home Style
2-Story (1909)
Lot Size
0.11 acres
Renovation
Full: HVAC, plumbing, electrical
Garage
1-car detached
HOA
None
Days on Market
1 day — multiple offers

About The Avenues, Salt Lake City

The Avenues is one of Salt Lake City’s oldest and most architecturally distinct neighborhoods, climbing up the foothills just north of downtown and the Utah State Capitol. Known for its grid of historic single-family homes — many dating to the late 1800s and early 1900s — The Avenues offers tree-lined streets, classic Victorian and Craftsman architecture, walkable streets, and easy access to downtown, the University of Utah, City Creek Canyon, and the LDS Hospital corridor.

Buyer demand in The Avenues has been remarkably consistent through changing market cycles, in part because the neighborhood’s housing stock is largely irreplaceable — you can’t build a 1909 turn-of-the-century home today. Renovated properties that combine original architectural detail with modern systems (like this one’s new HVAC, plumbing, and electrical) tend to attract competitive offers quickly. See more sold comparables and active listings on our The Avenues real estate page.

Thinking about selling your Utah home?

Keep more of your equity at closing with a reduced listing commission from DiscountAgent.com — full service, lower fees, zero gimmicks.

Learn About Our Listing Program
Or call Aaron directly: 801-243-8900

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a reduced listing commission, and how does it work?
+

A reduced listing commission means the seller pays a lower percentage (or flat fee) to the listing brokerage than the traditional 3% most agents charge. At DiscountAgent.com, our standard seller program is 1.5% on the listing side — a full 50% discount compared to the traditional rate — while still providing full MLS marketing, professional photography, pricing strategy, negotiation, and closing coordination. The buyer-side commission is negotiated separately and is not affected.

How does DiscountAgent.com differ from a flat-fee MLS service?
+

DiscountAgent.com provides full-service representation at a reduced commission — not a stripped-down flat-fee MLS-only listing. Limited-service flat-fee companies typically just put the home on the MLS and leave the seller to handle pricing, showings, negotiation, contracts, inspections, and closing on their own. We handle all of that, plus professional photography and active marketing — while still charging well below traditional commission rates. You can see a full side-by-side comparison on our DiscountAgent vs. Flat Fee Group page.

What is the flat-fee listing program mentioned in this post?
+

Our flat-fee listing program is a deeper discount available exclusively to past DiscountAgent.com clients as a thank-you for their repeat business. It replaces the percentage-based listing commission with a single flat fee. This program is not offered to the general public. Sellers who aren’t past clients still qualify for our standard 1.5% listing program, which typically saves thousands compared to a traditional 3% listing.

Is The Avenues a competitive seller’s market right now?
+

Yes — The Avenues consistently ranks among Salt Lake City’s most in-demand neighborhoods, and well-prepared homes often attract multiple offers quickly. This particular listing went under contract in one day with multiple offers. The combination of historic character, walkable streets, proximity to downtown and the University of Utah, and a limited supply of renovated turn-of-the-century homes keeps buyer demand strong even when the broader market shifts. Pricing strategy and presentation matter enormously here.

What schools serve homes near 457 N C Street?
+

This home was assigned to Ensign Elementary, Bryant Middle School, and West High School — all part of the Salt Lake City School District. Boundaries can shift between school years, so any buyer moving in should verify their specific address through the district’s online boundary lookup tool. Each school has its own website linked earlier in this post.

Are there special considerations when selling a historic Avenues home?
+

Yes — portions of The Avenues fall within Salt Lake City’s Avenues Historic District, which can affect exterior alterations, additions, and demolitions. When selling, it’s important to clearly disclose the home’s renovation history (especially major systems like HVAC, plumbing, and electrical), document any permits pulled, and price appropriately based on whether comparable homes have been similarly updated. A listing agent who knows the neighborhood and its buyer pool can position these features to attract the strongest possible offers.

How do I get started listing my home with DiscountAgent.com?
+

Call or text Aaron Peters directly at 801-243-8900, or visit our listing program page to request a free seller consultation. We’ll walk through your property, share live comparable sold data, outline a pricing strategy, and explain exactly what the reduced listing commission looks like for your specific situation — with no pressure and no obligation to move forward.

Ready to Keep More of Your Equity?

Let’s talk about what a reduced listing commission could mean for your Salt Lake City home sale. Free, no-pressure consultation — we’ll show you the live market data and let you decide.

See Our Listing Program
Or call Aaron Peters directly:
801-243-8900
Posted by Discount Agent on

Enjoy this blog post? Click here to subscribe for updates

Tags

Email Send a link to post via Email

Leave A Comment

e.g. yourwebsitename.com
Please note that your email address is kept private upon posting.